基于引文与网络链接的开放存取期刊学术影响力评价Scholarly Impact Measurements of Open Access Journals Based on Citations and Links
袁顺波;华薇娜;
摘要(Abstract)：
以图书馆学情报学的97份开放存取期刊为样本,采用基于引文的评价方法和基于网络链接的评价方法对开放存取期刊的学术影响力进行评价。结果表明图书馆学情报学开放存取期刊已经成为该领域学术交流的重要组成部分,Journal of Medical Library Association、D-Lib Magazine、Information Research、Ariadne、Cybermetrics和First Monday是图书馆学情报学最重要的6份开放存取期刊,基于引文的评价方法和基于网络链接的评价方法之间存在着一定的相关性。
关键词(KeyWords)： 开放存取期刊;引文分析;网络链接;学术影响力;学术评价
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Authors): 袁顺波;华薇娜;
参考文献(References)：
- 1Turoff,M&Hiltz,S.B.,The electronicjournal:a progress re-port.Journal of the American Society for Information Science,1982,33(4):195-202
- 2Koehler W.,Aguilar P.,Finarelli S.,Gaunce C.,Hatchette S.&Heydon R.et al.,A bibliometric analysis of select informa-tion science print and electronic journals in the1990s,Informa-tion Research,2000,6(1).[2010-02-10].http://Informa-tionR.net/ir/6-1/paper88.ht ml
- 3Hawkins.D.T.,Bibliometrics of electronic journals ininforma-tion science.Information Research,2001,7(1).[2010-02-10]http://informationr.net/ir/7-1/paper120.ht ml
- 4McVeigh M.E.,Open Access Journals in the ISI Citation Data-base:Analysis of I mpact Factors and Citation Patterns.[2010-02-10].http://www.thomsonisi.com/media/presnetrep/essay-spdf/openaccesscitations2.pdf
- 5Araqudiqe.N.,Kevin.C.A.Database Coverage and I mpact Factor of Open Access Journals in Pharmacy,Journal of Elec-tronic Resources in Medical Libraries,2009,6(2):138-145
- 6Ingwersen,P.,The calculation of Web I mpact Factors.Journal of Documentation,1998,54(2):236?243
- 7Borgman,C.;Furner,J.,Scholarly communication and biblio-metrics.Annual Reviewof Information Science and Technology,Medford,NJ:Information Today Inc.,2002:3-72
- 8Smith,A.G.,Citations and Links as a Measure of Effectiveness of Online LIS Journals.IFLAJournal,2005,31(1):76-84
- 9Kousha K.&Thel wall M.,Motivations for URL citations to open access library and information science articles.Scientomet-rics,2006,68(3):501-507
- 10Smith,A.G.,Atale of two Web spaces:Comparing sites u-sing Web i mpact factors.Journal of Documentation,1999,55(5):577-592
- 11Harter,S.,Ford,C.,Web-based analysis of E-journal i m-pact:Approaches,problems,andissues.Journal of the Ameri-can Society for Information Science,2000,51(13):1159-1176.
- 12Noruzi,A.,Google Scholar:The newgeneration of citationin-dexes.LIBRI,2005,55(4):170-180
- 13Bauer,K.&Bakkalbasi,N.,An examination of citation counts ina new scholarly communication environment.D-LibMagazine,2005,11(9).[2010-02-10].http://www.dlib.org/dlib/september05/bauer/09bauer.ht ml
- 14Vaughan,L.&Shaw,D.,Comparison of citations fromISI,Google,and Google Scholar:seeking web indicators of i mpact,Scientometrics,2008,74(2):317-330
- 15Mukherjee B.,Do Open-Access Journals in Library and Infor-mation Science Have Any Scholarly I mpact?A Bibliometric Study of Selected Open-Access Journals Using Google Scholar,Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology,2009,60(3):581-594
- 16马景娣.图书情报学电子期刊及其学术影响力分析.中国图书馆学报,2005(1):82-85,89
- 17马景娣.社会科学开放访问期刊及其学术影响力研究.情报资料工作,2005(02):47-49
- 18王学勤,韩仰东.开放访问期刊学术影响力的分析与评价.现代情报,2006(8):33-36
- 19胡德华,常小婉.开放存取期刊论文质量和影响力的评价研究.图书情报工作,2008,52(2):61-64
- 20查颖.利用H指数对OA期刊BMC Bioinformatics和传统期刊Bioinformatics的对比分析.现代情报,2008(6):5-6,4
- 21刘畅.开放存取期刊的影响力分析.图书情报工作,2008,52(12):9-12
- 22同6:236-243
- 23同8:76-84
- 24CSA Support Centre.[2010-02-10].http://support.csa.com/article.asp?article=2186&p=101