网络中心度用于期刊引文评价的有效性研究Validity of Journals Citation Evaluation with Centrality Indexes of Networks
高小强;赵星;陶乃航;
摘要(Abstract)：
以图书情报学期刊数据实证研究了网络中心度用于期刊引文评价的有效性。结果显示:中介、点度和特征向量中心度都比影响因子更接近同行评议的结果,可用于期刊引文评价;但接近中心度相对不宜用作期刊引文评价指标。
关键词(KeyWords)： 期刊;引文分析;引文网络;中心度;科学计量与信息计量
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Authors): 高小强;赵星;陶乃航;
参考文献(References)：
- 1 Ed itorial.Rating gam es.Nature.2005,436:889-890.
- 2 Kossinets G,Watts D J.Empirical analysis of an evolving social net-work.Science.2006,311(5757):88-90
- 3 Palla G,Barabasi A,Vicsek T.Quantifying social group evolution.Nature,2007,446(7136):664-667
- 4 Watts J.A twenty-first century science.Nature,2007,445(1):48.
- 5 Bar-Ilan.Informetrics at the beginning of the 21st century—A re-view.Journal of Informetrics,2008,2(1):1-52.
- 6 Scott J.Social Network Analysis:A Handbook.London:Sage Publi-cations,2000.
- 7 Lin N.Social Capital:A Theory of Social Structure and Action.Cam-bridge:Cambridge University Press,2001
- 8 Leydesdorff L.Visualization of the citation impact environments of sci-entific journals:An online mapping exercise.JASIST,2007,58(1):25-38.
- 9 Freeman C.Centrality in Social Networks:Conceptual Clarification.Social Networks,1978,1(3):215-239.
- 10 Everett M,Sinclair P,Dankelmann P.Some centrality results newand old.Journal Of Mathematical Sociology,2004,28(4):215-227
- 11 Carrington P,Scott J,Wasserman S.Models and Methods in SocialNetwork Analysis.New York:Cambridge University Press,2005.
- 12 Butler D.Free journal-ranking tool enters citation market.Nature,2008,451(7174):6
- 13赵星,高小强,唐宇.SJR与影响因子、h指数的比较及SJR的扩展设想.大学图书馆学报.2009,(2):80-84
- 14 Nisonger E,Davis C.The Perception of library and information sci-ence journals by LIS education deans and ARL library directors:AReplication of the Kohl-Davis study.College&Research Libraries,2005,66(4):341-377.
- 15 Garfield E.Citation analysis as a tool in journal evaluation.Science.1972;178:471-479
- 16 Agrawal A.Corruption of journal impact factors.TRENDS in Ecolo-gy and Evolution,2005,20,(4):157.
- 17 Butler L,Visser M.Extending citation analysis to non-source i-tems.Scientometrics,2006,66(2):327-343.
- 18 Lange L.The impact factor as a phantom:Is there a self-fulfillingprophecy effect of impact?Journal of Documentation,2002,58(2):75-184.
- 19 Mueller P,Murali N,Cha,S et al.The association between impactfactors and language of general internal medicine journals.SwissMedical Weekly.2006,136:441-443
- 20赵星,高小强.人际情报网络中的关键联系识别.图书情报工作,2008,52(11):26-29