郑德俊

• 1:南京农业大学信息管理系

摘要(Abstract)：

图书馆管理目标是通过馆员的努力为用户提供高质量的信息服务,图书馆服务质量控制是图书馆管理的重要内容。LibQUAL+TM是一种用户视角下的满意度测量,可以被看成是图书馆服务质量反馈控制的评价工具,ClimateQUALTM是一种馆员视角下的包含员工工作满意度的工作气候测评,可以被看成是图书馆服务质量过程控制的评价工具。该文从理论基础、测评指标、应用前景等方面对LibQUAL+TM与ClimateQUALTM进行了评析,并讨论了这两种评价工具在图书馆服务质量控制方面所体现的相关性。论文的结论是:LibQUAL+TM与Climate-QUALTM都可以为图书馆服务质量控制提供决策支持,面向图书馆服务质量控制的评价工具应是两者的协同运用,我们需要从观念培育、指标本地化改造、制度完善、测评结果利用等方面全面努力,建设能够协同运用两种评价工具的图书馆评估文化。

关键词(KeyWords)： 服务质量控制;用户满意度;组织气候;ClimateQUALTM;LibQUAL+TM

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 江苏省教育厅高校哲学社会科学基金项目“图书馆组织气候测评的结构模型研究”(2011SJD870007)成果之一

作者(Author): 郑德俊

参考文献(References)：

• 1 Nitecki D.A..Changing the concept and measure of service quali-ty in academic libraries.The Journal of Academic Librarianship,1996(5):181-190
• 2 Cook C.,Heath F..The Association of Research LibrariesLibQUAL+TM Project:An Update.ARL Newsletter:A Bi-monthly Report on Research Library Issues and Actions fromARL,CNI,and SPARC,2000,211:12-14
• 3 Kyrillidou M.,et al.ClimateQUALTM:Organizational Climateand Diversity Assessment.ACRL Fourteenth National Confer-ence,2009
• 4 Litwin G.H.,Stringer R.A..Motivation and organizational cli-mate.Boston:Graduate School of Business Administration Har-vard University,1968:28-82
• 5 Schneider B.,Parkington J.J.,Buxton V M.Employee and cus-tomer perceptions of service in banks.Administrative ScienceQuarterly,1980,25:252-267
• 6 Schneider B.,Bowen D.E..Employee and customer perceptionsof service banks:replication and extension.Journal of AppliedPsychology,1985,70(3):423-433
• 7 Schneider B.,White S.,Paul M.C..Linking Service Climateand Customer Perceptions of Service Quality:Test of a CausalModel.Journal of Applied Psychology,1998,83(2):150-163
• 8 Cronin J.J.,Taylor S.A..Measuring service quality:A reex-amination and extension.Journal of marketing,1992,56:55-68
• 9 Parasuraman A.,Zeithaml V.A.,Berry L.L.A ConceptualModel of Service Quality and Its Implications for Future Re-search.Journal of Marketing,1985,49:41-50
• 10 Nitecki D.A.Assessment of service quality in academic librar-ies:Focus on the applicability of the SERVQUAL.See.Proceed-ings of the Second Northumbria International Conference on Per-formance Measurement in Libraries and Information Services.England:University of Northumbria,1998:181-196
• 11 Andaleeb S.S.,Simmonds P.L..Explaining user satisfactionwith academic libraries:Strategic implications.College&Re-search Libraries,1998(59):156-167
• 12 Stamatopolos A.,Mackoy R..Effects of Library Instruction onUniversity.Students'Satisfaction with the Library:A longitudi-nal study.College&Research Libraries,1998(59):327
• 13 Hernon P.,Nitecki D.A..Service quality:A concept not fullyexplored.Library Trends,2001,49:687–708
• 14于良芝,古松,赵峥.SERVQUAL与图书馆服务质量评估:十年研究评述.大学图书馆学报,2005(1):151-57
• 15史继红.论LibQual作为图书馆服务质量评价工具的局限性.情报科学,2008(3):414-417
• 16 Edgar W.B..Questioning LibQUALTM:expanding its assess-ment of academic library effectiveness.Libraries and the Acade-my,2006,6(4):445-465
• 17 Thompson B.,Cook C.,Kyrillidou M.Concurrent validity ofLibQUALTMscores:What do LibQUALTMscores measure?TheJournal of Academic Librarianship,2005,31(6):517-522
• 18 Hiller S.,Self J..From Measurement to Management:UsingStatistics Wisely in Planning and Decision-Making.LibraryTrends,2004,54(1):129-155
• 19 Siggins J.A..Job Satisfaction and Performance in a ChangingEnvironment.Library Trends,1992,41(2):299-315
• 20 James L.R.,Jones A.P..Organizational climate:A review oftheory and research.Psychological Bulletin,1974,81(12):1096-1112
• 21 Schneider B.,Wheeler J.,Cox J..A passion for service:Usingcontent analysis to explicate service climate themes.Journal ofApplied Psychology,1992,77(5):705-716
• 22 Schneider B..The people make the place.Personnel Psychol-ogy,1987,40:437-453.
• 23郑德俊.图书馆组织气候评价初论.中国图书馆学报,2011(2):120-127
• 24 Harer J.B..Employees as customers judging quality:enhancingemployee assessment.New Library World,2008,109(7/8):307–320
• 25 Kyrillidou M.,Baughman S..ClimateQUALTM:OrganizationalClimate and Diversity Assessment.C&RL News,2009,70(3):154-157
• 26 Bryan L.,Barahona M..Highlights of the 2008ClimateQUALFindings.http://research.library.cornell.edu/pastprojects,2008-10-11
• 27 Heskett J.L.,Sasser Jr W E,Schlesinger L A.The ServiceProfit Chain:How Leading Companies Link Profit and Growth toLoyalty,Satisfaction,and Value.New York:Free Press,1997
• 28 Li Xin,Bryan L..On Becoming an Employer of Choice:Gaug-ing Employee Satisfaction Through ClimateQUALTM.LibraryTrends,2010,59(1-2):256-268
• 29 Curry A..Innovation in Public Service Management.ManagingService Quality,1999,9(3):180-190
• 30 Luk S.T.K.,Layton R..Perception Gaps in customer expecta-tions:Managers versus service providers and customers.TheService Industries Journal,2002,22(2):109-128
• 31 Levitt T..Production-line approach to service.Harvard Busi-ness Review,1992,11(9):41-52
• 32 Shostack G.L..Service Positioning Through Structural Change.The Journal of Marketing,1997,51(1):34-43
• 33 ARL.2008Library Assessment Conference:Building Effective,Sustainable,Practical Assessment.http://libraryassessment.org/archive/2008.shtml,2009-06-17
• 34Lock S.A.,Town J.S..libqual in the UK:A brief report on the UK pilot.SCONUL Newsletter,2003(29):8-10
• 35初景利.应用SERVQUAL评价图书馆服务质量.大学图书馆学报,1998(5):43-44
• 36吴冬曼等.网络环境下图书馆服务质量评价方法探析—清华大学图书馆读者满意度调查工作的实践与思考.大学图书馆学报,2006(1):49-52
• 37李晓东,卢振波.本地化读者调查问卷的定量评价研究.大学图书馆学报,2007(6):61—64
• 38施国洪,王治敏.图书馆服务质量评价研究回顾与展望.中国图书馆学报,2009(5):91-98
• 39Hiller S.,Kyrillidou M.,Self J..When the evidence is not e-nough:Organizational factors that influence effective and suc-cessful library.Performance Measurement and Metrics,2008,9(3):223-230
• 40O'Brien L.,Miller L.,Li Xin.What Do Users Think of Us?:Mining Three Years of CUL LibQUAL Data.[2008-05-21].http://research.library.cornell.edu/pastprojects